NKDS

NKDS – Come in to see everything inside that comes out eventually…
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Sales

Post AFA thoughts: The difference between a Gundam and… a Gundam.

Julius_Firefocht | November 24, 2008

Wing Zero, Kunio Okawara version

AFA has just successfully concluded, and I trust that it had been an enjoyable and memorable event for all who attended. After all, this is the first time a large scale anime event has been held in Singapore, and the management can only get better with experience. Let us hope for an even better event next year, one that will be spectacular enough to lure more fellow anime and mecha fans from our neighbouring countries into attending.

This will be among the first in a series of AFA-related articles that NKDS will be working on, as we try to work our fried brains into some semblance of competence while recalling details about the event. Aniki and May’n were responsible for this, they were the ones who made us shell-shocked with their awesome performances. Though I never knew the process of being shell-shocked felt so good.

While AFA 2008 as a whole was excellent, several observations made by NKDS personnel who attended Kunio Okawara’s autograph session caused some of the more mecha-inclined among us to become rather incensed, and with that in mind, we elected to dedicate a post to the phenomenon in question. This article has nothing to do with the organizers of AFA, instead it has everything to do about the fans, or more specifically, the Gundam fans who attended the event.

Wing Zero, Hajime Katoki version. Same Gundam, 2 designers.

Okawara-sensei recently received a boost in local fame thanks to his attendence at AFA, and he is widely and rightfully recognized by fans of the mecha genre as the foremost and leading Gundam mechanical designer. However, as some readers are no doubt aware, other mechanical designers have contributed their own Gundam designs before. A good example would be Hajime Katoki with his Gundam Wing Endless Waltz designs, and Kanetake Ebikawa, who designed the Gundam Exia and 00 Gundam from the currently airing Gundam 00.

Therein lies the problem. During Okawara-sensei’s autograph session, we spotted several fans carrying kits such as the MG Wing Zero Custom and 1/100 Gundam Exia, intended for Okawara-sensei to sign on. While this may be done in good faith and with no malice meant, Okawara-sensei himself had absolutely no involvement with those designs, and certainly has the right to refuse the autography request. Of course, the kind designer did nothing of the sort and signed on the model kits without complaint, but his sheer generosity only made what the fans unwittingly did to him sting even more than it should.

Personnel from Bonkurasu and Nakadashi witnessed for themselves what happened, and we truly felt for Okawara-sensei. It was such a sorry scene…an autograph session held in his honour, and he had Gundam fans bringing mobile suits not designed by him for him to sign on. Yet he easily took it in his stride and continued the session as if nothing unusual had happened. Our respect for him rose another few notches that afternoon.

So, that leads me to our message for Gundam or mecha fans in general, wherever you may hail from. Mechanical designers often treat their designs as their child, the product of a painful process of continuous refinement and improvement. We, as fans, in turn respect and celebrate the designers’ achievements by purchasing the merchandise of designs that we like, be it the humblest 1/144 model kit or a top-of-the-line Soul of Chogokin figure.

Therefore, please accord basic respect to designers and their works by at least doing some research and identifying who designed what, before diving into an autography session.

For a small investment of your time, you could save yourself a great deal of embarassment, and at the same time truly honour the designer by requesting for his signature on a merchandise of the design that he was personally involved in. The designer will be happier, his smile to you may be more personal and friendlier, especially if the design happened to be a personal favourite. You in turn will feel good about supporting the designer and having your merchandise autographed. Really, it is all benefits with zero drawbacks.

As I was telling Dodgethis, thank the Gundam gods that no one turned up with a VF-25 model kit for that session. That would have been an atrocity that any self-respecting mecha fan would have found hard to stomach, regardless of Okawara-sensei’s personal reaction. Not that Kawamori-sensei’s work is in any way inferior to Okawara-sensei’s, but having Okawara-sensei putting his name on a Valkyrie is just plain wrong.

This is Julius Firefocht, signing off.

Categories
Event, Purchases
Tags
gundam, Hajime Katoki, kunio okawara
Comments rss
Comments rss
Trackback
Trackback

« A Faptastic Affair At AFA08 Panzer IVs for Flames of War. »

10 responses

Great post, and indeed you're very right. I see no

tj han | November 24, 2008

Great post, and indeed you’re very right. I see no point in asking May’n to autograph a CD of Hamasaki Ayumi, and that’s the equivalent of this situation.

Thank god no one brought a VF to the session...

tueac | November 24, 2008

Thank god no one brought a VF to the session… that is mortally wrong…

But as for the other Gundams… I think it’s quite ok… given that Okawara Sensei is the FATHER of all things Gundam and he is the one that give Gundam the iconic look that is Gundam… Hence, that is why he can proudly put his name on the 2, Exia and Wing.

Also he is like the principle designer of Wing Zero… … Ver K.A is still just remix…

He can also choose to place his name on all those Zaku copycats… if he wants to…

Solid report and explanation to the clueless mecha and Gundam

ken0601 | November 24, 2008

Solid report and explanation to the clueless mecha and Gundam fans alike. They should do a good readup at Mahq at least before the session. But kudos to Okawara-sensei for being kind to the fans that turned up and signed the kits.

While i do see the sad painful truth behind this,

Aoshi | November 24, 2008

While i do see the sad painful truth behind this, and though insult is/was felt, you can’t always be too righteous. Given the situation, I would forgive them for the mistake. After all, they are still fans though the designer is different. Kunio Okawara in my opinion, as the principal Gundam designer has the right to stamp his name on the different Gundam designs though some weren’t made by him.

But the last thing i’d want is to see Kunio Okawara sign a Shoji Kawamori designed VF model kit. Lol.

@Aoshi Really, there was nothing for us to forgive. It is

Julius_Firefocht | November 24, 2008

@Aoshi

Really, there was nothing for us to forgive. It is not our place to judge the rights and wrongs of the acts of fandom, especially when Okawara-sensei himself graciously autographed their kits despite the difference in designers.

~~~

This article is not meant as an insult against some of the newer Gundam fans. On the contrary, it is meant to be an informative article designed to illuminate said fans to the fact that not all Gundams are designed by the same person, and therefore not all designers should sign their name on all Gundams. I can’t imagine Hajime Katoki putting his name down on a Zaku II model kit, for example.

If fans persist in this behaviour, not only will it reflect badly upon the local community; the prospect of future attendence of mecha designers in future events will be endangered. Imagine if word spreads around the tight-knit professional mecha design community back in Japan, that fans from a certain country disrespected a famous designer by asking him to sign on a merchandise of a work that another designer was responsible for. That, in turn, might cause other designers to refrain from visiting the country. After all, why oblige an unappreciative audience?

That would be disastrous, which is why this article was made in the first place… to try to prevent such an issue from ever befalling any one nation.

Of course, I am not so naive as to believe that every fan out there will immediately have their designer awareness raised, but if this article manages to cause even one more mecha fan to become more appreciative of a mecha design and its origins, then I consider the time spent writing this post to be well spent.

Oh my, didn't any AFA crew stop them? I thought

hika | November 25, 2008

Oh my, didn’t any AFA crew stop them? I thought it was stated that you would get him to sign only with the purchase of the MG gundam ver 2.0 model?

but then, its really is a good thing nobody bring the VF models for him to sign.

They did announce they were opening up the autograph session

dodgethis | November 25, 2008

They did announce they were opening up the autograph session to everyone. I was walking by and thought, why the hell not. Got my GaoGaiGar Final art book signed by him

[...] Kunio Okawara autorgraph session thoughts by Julius [...]

㊥出し » Anime Festival Asia Articles | November 25, 2008

[...] Kunio Okawara autorgraph session thoughts by Julius [...]

Didn't get any signatures myself...but if I were up there,

C.I. | November 25, 2008

Didn’t get any signatures myself…but if I were up there, damn, I’d have been honored to have him sign anything.

Excellent report and POV. Me and my friend had hoped

drifand | November 26, 2008

Excellent report and POV. Me and my friend had hoped to be let in for the session despite the ‘20 only’ limit set by Bandai. As such, we only brought small items that we personally felt connected with Ohkawara’s body of work. My friend brought the 20th Anniversary album of Gundam Illustrations with sensei’s paintings gracing the cover as well as a significant number of pages; I brought along a VOTOMS mini poster that was included for the recent reissue of the old Takara 1/24 scale Dual Model RSC.

While I couldn’t get inside, my friend did… and we both watched in horror at the items that were being carried in, just like you’ve reported. Anyway… when my friend got his turn, he could see sensei’s eyes light up in recognition of his own work and chatted for a bit about the 30th anniversary edition coming out next year. He was also pleased enough to indulge signing my mini poster as a second item. Much respect and gratitude to Ohkawara sensei!

Leave a comment

You can use these tags : <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Calendar

November 2008
S M T W T F S
« Oct   Dec »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  

Archives

Categories

Blogroll

  • 11~15% suki
  • Anime Raku
  • × • = bj0rN = • ×
  • Bonkurasu Brigade
  • Collateral Damage
  • Daiyaku
  • danie’s shopping log
  • Danny Choo
  • j1m0ne
  • Moeside
  • Mou Yamete!
  • PZ – New Point of ViewZ
  • Riuva
  • The Anime House Blog
  • The Banzai Effect
  • The Bunny……BUNNY???
  • 初音島・花より団子
  • 愛魔酢

Links

  • Ai Sp@ce
  • Anime Festival Asia 2009

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • WordPress.org
rss Comments rss valid xhtml 1.1 design by jide powered by Wordpress get firefox
Hosted by Reinforce Network